Can you rent out a unit in 36 Hamilton Avenue, Staten Island, NY?

36 Hamilton Avenue

Homeowners association in Staten Island, Richmond County, NY.

Can you rent in 36 Hamilton Avenue? Yes — rentals are allowed in 36 Hamilton Avenue, Staten Island, NY. Rental cap: 30 units subletting at a time (if the co-op reaches a 30-unit sublet threshold, subletting shareholders are not eligible to renew), per MLS remarks effective 4/1/24. Wait period: 3 years of ownership before subletting permitted (per MLS 2405297); one listing (MLS 481265, 4L) describes sublet terms running up to 5 years. Must own before renting: Not yet verified.

Verification: Reported from listing records. Brokerage building policy page; bylaws not located

Rental rules & HOA facts

Rentals allowed	Yes
Rental cap	30 units subletting at a time (if the co-op reaches a 30-unit sublet threshold, subletting shareholders are not eligible to renew), per MLS remarks effective 4/1/24
Wait period before renting	3 years of ownership before subletting permitted (per MLS 2405297); one listing (MLS 481265, 4L) describes sublet terms running up to 5 years
Owner-occupancy rule	Must own 3 years before subletting — owner-occupancy required for the first 3 years.
Co-op board & application	Co-op board approval required for purchasers; minimum 20% down payment; board reviews debt-to-income ratio, assets, down payment and credit score; annual income requirement (per unit 4L). No dogs — cats only. Application fees apply. Board meeting frequency and interview format: unverified.
Ownership type	Co-op
Community address	36 Hamilton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10301
Last verified	2026-10-01

Know the HOA dues, fees, or contact info for 36 Hamilton Avenue? Help complete this listing →

Own or manage this HOA? Claim and update this listing →

St. George co-op (120 units, built 1963). Compass building page lists 'Rental/Sublet Policy: Allowed' and 'Rentals Allowed'. No rental ban or cap found in public sources.

Data compiled from public records, MLS remarks, and HOA/management sources. Rules change — confirm directly with the HOA before buying or leasing.

Special assessments

$0 (one-time) — Unit 4A (MLS 2405297): monthly capital assessment of $64.01 on top of $597 maintenance. Unit 4L (MLS 481265): $769/mo maintenance plus $84/mo for capital improvements through December 2024. Ongoing capital assessment of $64.01/mo is current as of the 4A listing.
Reported 2026-10-04 via research.

Assessments change — verify current amounts with the HOA before buying.

Ida MazzolaKeller Williams Realty Staten IslandStaten Island real estate broker.Learn more →

More HOAs in Staten Island, NY

← Search all HOA communities on HOA411

Robert DeFalco JrRobert DeFalco RealtyNY & NJ realtor.Learn more →